Auto Consumer Anxiety Presents Opportunity
A survey of U.S. drivers found the majority are concerned about finances and the economy, but those fears make many ready to buy vehicle-protection products.

Fifty-four percent of poll respondents said they prefer to do their own products research, and 69% want pressure-free learning.
Pexels/Pixabay
A spring survey of U.S. consumers shows they’re concerned about the financial hit of buying a car today, but the findings also reveal ample opportunity to sell protection products.
Finance-and-insurance product provider Protective Asset Protection polled more than 3,000 drivers in April on their views about financial conditions and vehicle protection plans.
The results showed 69% were concerned about finances as they bought their vehicles. The silver lining in the stark finding came when consumers shared their likelihood of paying for protection products: 29% said today’s economic conditions make them more likely to do so.
Though that’s a significant share of respondents, another 56% said the same conditions make them less likely to buy F&I products.
“For dealers, this bifurcation represents a coaching opportunity rather than a conversion problem,” Protective said.
“The consumers already motivated by financial self-protection are the most ready for a transparent, value-forward conversation. And those who are hesitant often share the same underlying concern: they want to understand whether a product is genuinely worth it.”
Respondents cited the usual suspects when asked about the potential car issues they’d wish to hedge against: major mechanical breakdowns, such as the engine and transmission; electrical components, which have become a leading cause of auto recalls; and the kind of advanced technological features that are more common today.
Consequently, 49% of respondents named vehicle service contracts as the most valuable protection product, followed by 31% who cited gap coverage. Protective reported that 22% of respondents said they plan to buy a VSC, the leading target product.
Consumers said clear coverage explanations, examples of repair costs, information on flexible payment options, and the belief that they’re buying from a reputable provider as top motivations to buy products.
“Telling a customer that an engine replacement can cost $5,000 to $8,000 and showing them how a VSC eliminates that exposure is exactly the kind of conversation this survey shows buyers are ready to have,” the report points out.
Dealers should offer F&I product information online, Protective advised, because 54% of poll respondents said they prefer to do their own products research, and 69% want pressure-free learning.
Originally posted on F&I and Showroom
More F&I

Parsing Out Profits
As auto dealers have had to settle for normalized bottom lines after reveling in unprecedented pandemic-era highs, product sales have cushioned the fall.
Read More →
To Include Products in the First Pencil or Not
In this month's Under the Hood, Editor Hannah Mitchell examines a question many auto dealers have been asking since Federal Trade Commission enforcement intensified this year.
Read More →
Get Ahead of the Change
A strong culture, among other things, will be a key differentiator for auto dealerships as the market speeds ahead to new heights, says industry veteran Joel Kansanback.
Read More →
F&I Without the Handoff
Get more familiar with what your dealer clients are really buying when they entrust you with finance-and-insurance.
Read More →
Affordability Shapes Auto Demand
Auto originations increased 1% in the first quarter, and electric vehicles are rebounding, according to TransUnion's latest credit report.
Read More →
The Evolution of Agency Development in Modern F&I
General agents have a different roadmap for success than their predecessors. It will pay for them to follow it in order to be true dealer partners.
Read More →
Four-Figure Loan Payments on the Rise
A LendingTree analysis found that location, age and credit score play a role in the rising amount of auto loan borrowers who make monthly payments of $1,000 or more.
Read More →
APCO Holdings Acquires Fidelity Dealer Services
The finance-and-insurance product provider says the addition strengthens EasyCare’s reach across key markets.
Read More →
Tariffs Could Raise Insurance Premiums
As U.S. import tariffs affect repair costs, consumers might find it more affordable to replace a damaged vehicle, according to recent Insurify tariff analysis.
Read More →
Smaller Loans, Longer Terms
The youngest generation of car buyers is more likely to finance less expensive vehicles, more than half of generation Z consumers borrowing less than $25,000.
Read More →