Wells Fargo Reviewing F&I Products as Regulatory Pressure Builds
SAN FRANCISCO — Wells Fargo is reviewing all F&I products customers opt to include in vehicle finance contracts the bank purchases from dealers to “improve processes for our consumer and dealer customers and to remain competitive in the market,” bank officials said in a statement. The statement was issued to F&I and Showroom in response to questions ... Read More »
SAN FRANCISCO — Wells Fargo is reviewing all F&I products customers opt to include in vehicle finance contracts the bank purchases from dealers to “improve processes for our consumer and dealer customers and to remain competitive in the market,” bank officials said in a statement.
The statement was issued to F&I and Showroom in response to questions about an April 8 article in The Wall Street Journal. Citing people familiar with the matter, the article claimed the bank has expanded its internal review of GAP refunds to other F&I protections like vehicle service contracts and tire protection to “get ahead of heightened regulatory interest in the area.”
The bank’s statement, however, notes that the review “is part of our well-publicized efforts to continually improve and build a better auto lending business.”
“Wells Fargo does not sell auto aftermarket products — they are sold by dealers to their customers during the purchase of a vehicle,” read the statement, in part. “Wells Fargo buys loans from dealers that are inclusive of the financing of the vehicle and the optional aftermarket products.”
The issue regarding the bank’s handling of GAP refunds arose just after the bank announced last August that it would begin issuing refunds to more than half a million customers affected by issues related to sales of collateral protection insurance. In a recent filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the bank estimated that it will pay approximately $145 million in cash remediation and $37 million in account adjustments under its plan.
According to media reports, the GAP refund issue was raised in the course of an external inquiry ordered by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. In a statement issued to The New York Times just after the story broke, however, a Wells Fargo spokesperson said the company “discovered issues related to a lack over oversight and controls” during an internal review.
“We are reviewing our practices and actively working with our dealers and have already begun making improvements to the GAP refund process,” the statement read, in part. “If we find customer impacts, we will make customers whole.”
In an August 2017 regulatory filing, the bank noted that “certain issues related to the unused portion of guaranteed asset protection waiver or insurance agreements … which may result in refunds to customers in certain states.” Nine states require insurance providers to return unused insurance funds to customers: Alabama, Colorado, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, Oregon, and South Carolina.
According to The Wall Street Journal, Wells Fargo formed an internal working group in the second half of 2017 to review aftermarket products more broadly in response to consumer complaints and regulatory interest. The group’s activities, which the bank began sharing with the OCC and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau earlier this year, included surveying a group of customers to see if they were aware of aftermarket products on their auto loans and to gauge their satisfaction with the products, as well as reviewing dealer relationships to see which ones have the most complaints regarding products.
In recent months, according to The Wall Street Journal, Wells Fargo executives have discussed whether “a certain level of aftermarket services or other financial guidelines would trigger additional review of a loan,” but no action has been taken, according to the report.
Aftermarket products account for $2 billion, or 5%, of the bank’s $55 billion in outstanding auto loan balances. Interest earned on these loans totals between $100 million and $150 million a year, according to The Wall Street Journal’s report.
Additionally, around 70% of Wells Fargo’s auto loans included aftermarket products, people familiar with the bank’s auto portfolio told The Wall Street Journal. They added that the cost of these products can exceed $1,000 and sometimes approach 15% of the vehicle’s value.
In a November regulatory filing, Wells Fargo said allegations related to both CPI sales, which the bank has discontinued, and GAP refunds are the subject of two shareholder derivative lawsuits in California state court. The filing also revealed that “a former team member has alleged retaliation for raising concerns regarding automobile lending practices.”
“These and other issues related to the origination, servicing and/or collection of consumer automobile loans, including related insurance products, have also subjected the company to formal or informal inquiries, investigations or examinations from federal and state government agencies,” the filing notes.
More Industry

Nebraska Rooftop Changes Hands
The Gregg Young Automotive Group has sold its second dealership to Janssen Auto Group, both in Plattsmouth, Neb.
Read More →
Penske Auto Group Deal a Record
The deal to take the dealership and transportation services company private sets a new pace for industry buy-sell transactions.
Read More →
War Toll a Damper on Used Auto Prices
Cox Automotive found wholesale depreciation to be elevated in September amid high fuel prices and this year's unusual hurricane season.
Read More →
Bridge the Maintenance Gap
With many drivers missing recommended maintenance, service departments offering transparency and efficiency have a better chance of reaching financially strained consumers.
Read More →
California Store Has New Owner
The longtime dealership in the northern part of the state is known for robust fleet sales and has served the state capital for 115 years.
Read More →
BMW Plant Pursues Cleaner Energy
BMW Group Plant Leipzig has utilized hydrogen to help power its production since 2013, but a new pipeline is planned to take it to another level.
Read More →
Auto Affordability Inches Up
The latest Cox Automotive and Moody’s Analytics index shows a slight increase in new-vehicle affordability despite high prices.
Read More →
Ohio Auto Group Under New Ownership
After 79 years with the Schluter family, Mansfield Auto Group has been acquired by Missouri-based Clement Auto Group.
Read More →
RV Group Expands Carolina Footprint
Blue Compass RV Columbia Northeast is the 13th RV dealership owned by Blue Compass in the Carolinas.
Read More →
Agent Acumen
An Agent Summit panel of people who’ve been supporting auto dealers for years gave both timely and timeless advice for those starting out or mulling the prospect.
Read More →