W. Va. Attorney General Files Suit Against Used-Car Dealer
CHARLESTON, W.Va. — Earlier this month, West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey announced that his office filed suit in Cabell County Circuit Court against Downtown Used Auto Sales, alleging numerous violations of the West Virginia Consumer Credit and Protection Act and other applicable consumer protection laws and regulations.
The Office of the Attorney General first opened an investigation into Downtown Used Auto Sales in September 2012 after receiving numerous complaints from consumers. At the time the suit was filed, the office had received 22 formal complaints alleging a wide range of violations of the state’s consumer protection laws in the sale and financing of used motor vehicles.
The allegations included that owner Thomas J. Matthews sold unsafe vehicles, refused to repair significant mechanical defects, added unlawful finance charges, repossessed vehicles without the required legal notices and illegally disposed of consumers’ personal property. The office issued an investigative subpoena to the car dealer on April 25, 2013, which asked for documents and information about his sales and financing practices.
The filing summarizes 18 consumer complaints that illustrate the serious issues that consumers encountered with Downtown Used Auto Sales, including the sale of vehicles with mechanical defects, vehicles that could not pass inspection, illegal finance charges and fees, and repossessions without the required notices.
“In one of the examples included within the allegations, a consumer had her vehicle — which was not even able to pass inspection — repossessed without notice as required by law,” Morrisey said. “When she called them to ask about retrieving her personal belongings in the car — including her college textbooks, her bible, and an infant’s car seat — she was told the vehicle had been ‘cleaned out’ already, and all of her possessions were discarded.”
The suit asks the court to enter an order prohibiting Matthews from violating the West Virginia Consumer Credit and Protection Act, and also asks the court to award civil penalties to the state and restitution to all consumers who have been aggrieved by the dealership’s practices.
“Many used car dealers provide a valuable service by offering affordable, reliable vehicles to consumers who may not be able to obtain credit from mainstream lenders,” Morrisey said. “However, being willing to extend credit under those circumstances doesn’t excuse a dealer from its basic obligations under our state’s consumer protection laws.”
More Industry

Autos More Appealing
Consumers gave new cars better scores again this year for design, performance and more as mass-market brands kept gaining on premium lineups, JD Power found in an annual poll.
Read More →
Used EVs Defy Overall Market
While the used-car market saw three months of price declines or stagnation, the used EV segment did the opposite – rising for three straight months.
Read More →
Gone to the Dogs
A Stellantis brand decided to have some fun with one of its SUVs’ design to address growing emphasis on family pets.
Read More →
OEM Poll Sees Industry Evolution
Kerrigan Advisors’ survey of automakers finds that tariffs, technology, network tightening and other factors are poised to reshape auto retail.
Read More →
Luxe N.C. Dealerships Change Hands
A collection of Italian and English brand franchises were handed off to the owner’s friend in the business and include the Carolinas’ only Ferrari retail stores.
Read More →
Exposure Drives Interest in Chinese Cars
At a recent demonstration, consumers had the chance to ride in a Chinese-branded vehicle, a firsthand experience that improved their perceptions and purchase intent.
Read More →
Automotive Consumers Sink Further in Debt
Most financing metrics hit records in the second quarter as more buyers locked themselves into long terms and high monthly payments.
Read More →
Agent Advocate
Rob Mancuso, who comes from a long line of auto dealers, values general agents’ place in the industry and makes a case for them taking an even bigger seat at the table.
Read More →
Driving Under Distraction
Though consumers gave higher marks to new vehicles in JD Power’s most recent initial-quality poll, high-tech interference worsened, pointing to craving for simplicity.
Read More →
Affordable New Cars a Thing of the Past
More than one out of five new vehicles sell for more than $60,000, according to Edmunds. That's up 7% compared to prepandemic 2019.
Read More →