Auto insurance consumers’ trust of insurers is low, negatively affecting satisfaction and brand advocacy.
Over half, or 51%, of the more than 41,000 people who responded to a J.D. Power survey said they have low trust in their insurers.
But despite rate hikes, insurers can gain trust by managing expectations.

U.S. auto insurance rates are up 11% on average over the past year, but insurers are still losing an average of five cents on the dollar in collected premium.
Pexels/Vlad Deep
Auto insurance consumers’ trust of insurers is low, negatively affecting satisfaction and brand advocacy.
Over half, or 51%, of the more than 41,000 people who responded to a J.D. Power survey said they have low trust in their insurers.
One way auto insurers can gain trust is by better managing rate increases, the survey shows. Remarkably, trust levels were almost exactly the same among consumers who fully understood the reasons for a rate increase and expected it as consumers whose insurers cut their rates, or 735 and 736, respectively, on a 1,000-point scale, J.D. Power said.
That’s significant because, despite U.S. auto insurance rates up 11% on average over the past year, the company said insurers are still losing an average of five cents on the dollar in collected premium.
Trust in auto insurers varies depending on which of 11 surveyed regions the consumer lives, and the study found customers in Florida have the lowest level, not surprisingly since rate increases there are more frequent.
The survey, conducted in the eight months ended in April, is in its 25th year.

The South Korean automaker said it supports 570,000 jobs in the U.S. with a planned investment of $26 billion between 2025 and 2028, according to President and CEO José Muñoz.
Read More →
GM says more than 750 dealers across the U.S. are enrolled in CarBravo and that in January CarBravo dealers sold over two times the certified volume of Chevrolet, Buick and GMC dealers using traditional CPO.
Read More →A longtime newspaper journalist, Bobit Dealer Group's editor was raised on news back in the South. Now she brings that news-hound ethic to our four auto retail magazines.
Read More →
This session is designed to equip general agents with actionable strategies that can help their dealers enhance the efficiency of financial services managers.
Read More →
A flat national rate despite inflation and other financial challenges shows industry loyalty stability, annual Reynolds and Reynolds research finds.
Read More →
Over half of insurance holders ages 18 to 29 reported to be 'somewhat' likely to change providers in the next 90 days, according to CivicScience, which found that interest was lower among older age groups.
Read More →
Total visits to dealer websites from generative artificial intelligence platforms grew more than 15 times year-over-year, signaling a shift in how many consumers shop for cars online.
Read More →
In the U.S., Honda has the most efficient gas-electrified combo lineup while Tesla beats all automakers in annual EPA ranking as brands built their alternative-fuel offerings.
Read More →
Deal volume ebbed and flowed throughout 2025, but product performance remained steady, according to automotive technology and data intelligence solutions provider StoneEagle.
Read More →
Americans’ view of present business conditions, the labor market and family finances, though, are still in the dumps, and if they plan to buy cars, many target used units.
Read More →