agent Entrepreneur logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

G.M. Suits Will Proceed as One Case in New York

June 11, 2014
4 min to read


A panel of federal judges handed General Motors a modest but meaningful victory on Monday, consolidating the pretrial phase of more than 80 lawsuits against the company into a single proceeding in Manhattan — the venue sought by the automaker, reported The New York Times.


It came as the embattled company prepared to face investors on Tuesday in what is expected to be a tense annual shareholders meeting, the company’s first since it began recalling millions of defective small cars in February.

Ad Loading...


The cases, most seeking class-action status, have been filed around the country on behalf of owners of Chevrolet Cobalts, Saturn Ions and other cars that G.M. recalled this year for a defective ignition switch. Owners are seeking compensation for lost value of the vehicles and other economic damages from the company’s decade-long failure to address a safety problem that it now links to 13 deaths.


G.M.’s ultimate strategy is to have the cases dismissed, and toward that end, it has asked Judge Robert E. Gerber of the United States Bankruptcy Court in the Southern District of New York to rule that the cases violate a provision of the company’s July 10, 2009, restructuring agreement that protects it from legal claims stemming from incidents before that date. (Most of the recalled cars were manufactured before 2009.)


The ruling by a seven-judge panel on Monday puts the cases in the same district as Judge Gerber — though this proceeding will be overseen in District Court by Judge Jesse M. Furman — and is thought by some legal observers to be potentially more favorable to G.M. because of the familiarity with the issues involving the automaker’s bankruptcy.


G.M., which disputes that the cars have lost any value, welcomed the decision with a written statement Monday afternoon.


“This order affirms what we’ve maintained all along,” the company said. “All cases should be transferred to the Southern District of New York, which is in the best position to coordinate with the Bankruptcy Court’s proceedings, has previously heard appeals from the Sale Order and Injunction, decided several contested matters relating to the asset sale and where several of the ignition switch actions filed to date are pending.”

Ad Loading...


The panel’s ruling called the venue “the most appropriate choice,” citing the Southern District’s handling of the bankruptcy proceedings of G.M. and Delphi, its parts supplier. Lawyers for various cases had argued aggressively for a number of locations, including Chicago, Texas and Southern California, where the litigation against Toyota over unintended acceleration was consolidated.


None of this legal wrangling involves the cases filed against the company over personal injury and wrongful death from the ignition switch flaw. G.M. is hoping to resolve those claims outside of the courts with a compensation system devised by Kenneth R. Feinberg, the lawyer who has overseen victims’ funds in a number of cases, including the Boston Marathon bombings and the BP oil rig explosion.


The pretrial phase covers discovery and other evidence-gathering, and consolidating that portion of multiple cases is a common way of streamlining similar litigation. If the parties do not reach a settlement in pretrial, the cases will revert back to the courts where they were filed.


The panel’s decision came a day before G.M.’s annual shareholder meeting, a session that is expected to be tense after the release last week of a scathing report on the company’s handling of the ignition switch issue, written by Anton R. Valukas, a former United States attorney hired to conduct an internal investigation.


In recent years, the annual meeting, held at G.M. headquarters in Detroit, has been uneventful and sparsely attended. But interest is expected to be far greater this year as some investors are becoming concerned about the company’s mounting financial exposure from claims over the ignition flaw.

Ad Loading...


During the meeting, shareholders will get their first opportunity to hear about the crisis directly from Mary T. Barra, the chief executive. Ms. Barra will hold a news conference before the meeting, which will be run by the chairman of G.M.’s board, Theodore M. Solso.


Other than to express support for Ms. Barra and her management team, Mr. Solso and other directors have been largely silent since G.M. began recalling millions of defective small cars in February.


Board members, however, have been named as defendants in several lawsuits by shareholders, who allege that G.M.’s failure to disclose the switch problems for years has unfairly hurt the value of their stock.


G.M. has already set aside $1.7 billion to pay for the switch recall and dozens of other safety recalls it has issued this year. The company’s stock price is down 10 percent from the beginning of the year, a period when the market overall has risen to record heights.


Family members of accident victims were in Detroit on Monday to protest G.M.’s handling of the long-delayed recall before the meeting. Among the protesters was Laura Christian, birth mother of Amber Marie Rose, who died in a Cobalt crash in 2005.

Ad Loading...


Ms. Christian contended that G.M. has deliberately minimized the number of people who died as a result of the faulty switch, which can suddenly cut engine power and deactivate air bags. “The number is well over a hundred and growing,” she said.

More Industry

Group photo of men outside storefront.
Industryby Hannah MitchellMay 28, 2026

Pennsylvania Dealership Under New Retailers

The sale of the Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram store puts a family auto group on a leaner path as first-time dealers take the helm.

Read More →
Hallway with lockered wiring and computer
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMay 28, 2026

Battery Storage Takes Priority Over EVs

U.S. automakers are prioritizing battery energy stationary storage over electric-vehicle production as the consumer demand for EVs lags the rest of the world.

Read More →
Gray-scale photo of a line of Mini cars in a dealership parking lot
Industryby Hannah MitchellMay 27, 2026

Auto Dealers Feel Better But Not Great

A second-quarter Cox Automotive poll of franchised retailers and independents found better views of the current market after a good spring but anticipation of third-quarter storminess.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Closeup photo of the front of a white car
Industryby Hannah MitchellMay 21, 2026

New-Vehicle Sales Picture Relative

A May forecast is complicated by last spring’s trade tariff effects on auto retail. Despite continued hard realities, many consumers took advantage of ways to bite the bullet.

Read More →
Nissan logo on front of building
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMay 21, 2026

Auto Group Acquires Third Nissan Rooftop

Iowa-based Coleman Automotive Group recently acquired its seventh dealership, McGrath Nissan, which it renamed Nissan of Elgin.

Read More →
Couple talking with auto salesman next to new car inside dealership
Industryby Hannah MitchellMay 20, 2026

April Less Affordable

Based on prices, reduced incentives and slower household income growth, consumers found it more challenging to buy new last month, Cox Automotive reported.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Wooden people figures of different colors in a row, similar to board game pieces
IndustryMay 20, 2026

Building an Extraordinary F&I Agency

Work to determine your specialized talent, because that fact will determine everything about your agency’s future.

Read More →
Ingredient card, policies and procedures, fixed operations, variable operations, data security, audit
Industryby Jim GantherMay 19, 2026

Recipe for Compliance

The secret to both amazing barbecue and compliance is the same: understanding the basics and committing to a process.

Read More →
Photo of new Chevrolet Bolt parked on a beach
Industryby Hannah MitchellMay 14, 2026

EVs Getting More Attractive

A growing percentage of U.S. consumers are open to switching and fewer are adverse to the idea, according to a recently completed survey. That’s despite the end of a tax break.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Benchmark bar graph showing April 2026 EV Sales
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMay 14, 2026

EV Sales Drop in April Following Surge

North American electric-vehicle sales were down 28% year-over-year, a sharp contrast from global EV sales growth of 6%.

Read More →
Ad Loading...