agent Entrepreneur logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Break-Even Equation for GM

October 27, 2010
4 min to read


As General Motors Co. plans its initial public offering for next month, and readies its "road show" for the sale next week, some bankers and analysts say the shares could reach a high enough price for the U.S. to come close to breaking even on its 2009 bailout of the carmaker, The Wall Street Journal reported.


But there's one big caveat: The stock would have to remain at that price over the many months or perhaps years it will take the government to sell its GM majority stake.

Ad Loading...


The U.S. Treasury is under pressure from banks underwriting the deal to maximize the number of shares it sells in the IPO, which is expected to take place about Nov. 18, said people familiar with the situation. The banks want to make sure there are enough shares to meet investor demand.


The Treasury is seeking to sell roughly $6 billion to $8 billion of its GM stock through the IPO, with other sellers taking the entire deal to a total of roughly $10 billion to $12 billion.


The government paid $40 billion for its stake, and risks political fallout if the share price sinks due to releasing too many shares at once on the market. That could send a signal the Obama administration won't recoup its investment.


While estimates of GM's stock valuation vary widely, one analyst at a research firm focusing on distressed companies said GM has a current implied market value of about $70 billion.


That calculation by Kirk Ludtke of CRT Capital Group LLC in Stamford, Conn., indicates a value for the U.S. stake of $35 billion, roughly $5 billion short of what the Treasury still has invested in the Detroit auto maker.

Ad Loading...


Ludkte said his measurement is based on the current trading price of GM's public debt. He thinks GM's market value could even top $82 billion six months after the IPO—potentially enough for the government to show a small profit.


The CRT calculation is in line with what some others are saying. Two bankers close to the IPO estimate the market value could be $60 billion to $70 billion.


Linda Killian, a principal of Renaissance Capital LLC in Greenwich, Conn., which specializes in IPO research, estimates GM's valuation at $50 billion to $70 billion, yet added that the chances of the government breaking even are "low."


Because the IPO should take place at a discount to the market price, the government is likely to show a big loss in realized proceeds on its sales on IPO day.


If the IPO is priced at the $50 billion level, that would equate to a U.S. loss of approximately 38 percent on the first batch of shares it sells.

Ad Loading...


Also, because there will be so much GM stock still to be sold even after the IPO, that will weigh on its valuation, Killian said. "Potential buyers are going to take that into consideration," she said.


Former investment banker and ex-White House auto czar Steven Rattner said Wednesday that any losses the U.S. will sustain from its investment "will be single digit" billions.


GM plans to launch its road show presentations to institutional investors for the IPO shortly after Election Day next Tuesday, in hopes of pricing and selling the shares shortly before Thanksgiving.


As part of the road show, GM Chief Executive Daniel Akerson, who took his post Sept. 1, will lead two teams of senior executives who will try to persuade investors to buy the stock, said people familiar with the matter.


One team will include GM Vice Chairman Steve Girsky, finance Vice President Dan Ammann and North America President Mark Reuss.

Ad Loading...


The other will include Chief Financial Officer Chris Liddell, manufacturing chief Tim Lee and product chief Tom Stephens. Akerson will trade off between the groups.


Stops are planned at about 10 cities in the U.S., Canada and Europe, but not Asia, said the people familiar with the plans.


Akerson and Girsky already have made trips to Asia and the Middle East in order to talk to investors and money managers.


Some money managers say they would be leery of GM stock at the price levels being discussed.


"Would I jump at the GM deal? Probably not," said Jack Ablin, chief investment officer of Harris Private Bank in Chicago. He said the "overhang of government ownership" results in a "management straitjacket" that could require GM executives to "get permission every time they want to extend a bonus to somebody."

More Industry

Photo of man with most of his face hidden as he types on a computer keyboard
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 2, 2026

Fake Auto Dealer Websites Frauding Consumers

The Point Predictive study traced a pattern across more than 100 websites it believes are being developed by an international theft ring.

Read More →
photo of Volkswagen vehicle steering wheel and interior
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 1, 2026

One of Earliest U.S. Auto Dealers Exits

The sale of two Minnesota franchises ends a rare multigenerational business while adding to one of the Midwest’s biggest auto groups.

Read More →
chart showing the quarterly electric vehicle market share from 2020-2025
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 27, 2026

EV Sales Slide While Hybrids Climb

California, as usual, led the country in EV registrations in the fourth quarter, but the U.S. as a whole saw a 43% year-over-year volume decrease.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of new car's tail light
Industryby Hannah MitchellMarch 26, 2026

New-Vehicle Sales Ride Tax Returns Wave

Forecasts show that the spring sales season is rising above overriding economic concerns, among them continuously rising car prices, trade tariffs, elevated interest rates, and now a war.

Read More →
Photo of Toyota car parked in front of a Toyota dealership
Industryby Hannah MitchellMarch 23, 2026

2025 Dealership Buy-Sells a Record

The Kerrigan Index shows that despite a chaotic year of musical trade tariffs, high vehicle prices and more roadblocks, acquirers still flush with pandemic-era cash accelerated the consolidation pace.

Read More →
Infographic from ABB titled “The Intelligent Factory is Accelerating as Automation Investment Increases.” It shows a robotic manufacturing assembly line on the left and key statistics on the right. Highlights include: 33% of manufacturers prioritize cost control, 31% are increasing investment in automation and robotics, 30% cite labor shortages and rising wages as challenges, and 34% identify energy and material costs as a leading concern. Additional sections explain competitive pressures and how automation technologies like robots improve efficiency, consistency, and productivity in modern manufacturing.
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 19, 2026

Automation Acceleration Seen in Manufacturing

Labor shortages, material costs and tariffs are just a few of the reasons automakers are looking to expand their investments in automation and robotics this year.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Overhead view of container cargo ship loaded with vehicles
Industryby Hannah MitchellMarch 19, 2026

War Threatens Major U.S. Auto Exports Stream

The Middle East imports a sizable share of vehicles made in the states. It’s unclear how the Iran War could affect the keystone market for U.S. automakers.

Read More →
five people sitting in a row with paperwork, Retention Requires Strategy, Agent Entrepreneur logo
Industryby Hannah MitchellMarch 17, 2026

Hiring That Sticks

Auto dealers don’t have to settle for high employee turnover. Despite historical patterns of rotating dealership doors, they can tweak their processes to find and keep the right people on staff.

Read More →
row of cars, used vehicle demand spikes, chart showing data spike, F&I and Showroom logo
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceMarch 11, 2026

Used Market Gains Speed

New-vehicle sales fell year-over-year for the fifth month in a row in February, making retail deliveries the slowest they’ve been since 2023, according to a CarGurus report.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic showing used-vehicle days to turn rate
Showroomby StaffMarch 10, 2026

Black Book: Weekly Market Update

Both vehicle values and conversion rates sped up last week as two segments outperformed in the pre-spring burst of buying.

Read More →