agent Entrepreneur logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

GOP Presidential Candidates Criticize Auto Bailout

November 7, 2011
5 min to read


WASHINGTON — The eight major Republican presidential candidates don't agree on everything — but all oppose the decision by Congress and President George W. Bush to approve a $700 billion bailout fund for banks, insurance companies and the auto industry.


Republicans denounce the $85 billion bailout of the auto industry. They argue it was a giveaway to the United Auto Workers union ahead of other creditors because a union health care trust fund got large stakes in General Motors and Chrysler.

Ad Loading...


At a CNN debate in June, moderator John King asked: "Is there anyone here who, given that prospect, and President Bush started the program, given that prospect, anyone here who would have stepped in and said, 'I don't want to do this, but this is the backbone of American manufacturing, I'll do something?'"


No one supported it.


President Barack Obama has repeatedly touted his unpopular decision to save General Motors Co. and Chrysler Group LLC and made it a touchstone of his re-election strategy.


The president has visited seven Big Three auto plants since taking office — and visited Detroit on Labor Day. He has argued that Republicans were willing to let General Motors and Chrysler Group LLC fail and repeatedly said: "Don't bet against American workers."


Obama's advisers were split in March 2009 over whether to save Chrysler; Obama agreed to an additional bailout for Chrysler if it tied up with Fiat SpA.

Ad Loading...


His advisers have noted the heavy toll a collapse of GM and Chrysler could have had on the Midwest. Former auto adviser Steve Rattner said Michigan could have been forced to file for bankruptcy if GM and Chrysler had liquidated.


Obama chides his opponents who weren't willing to step in.


"There were a lot of politicians who said it wasn't worth the time and wasn't worth the money. In fact, there are some politicians who still say that," he said Oct. 14 at GM's Orion Assembly. "The investment paid off. The hundreds of thousands of jobs that have been saved made it worth it.


Republicans point to the fact that the Treasury Department estimates it will lose $14.3 billion on the auto bailouts. Others argue the administration could have taken a tougher line in crafting the bailouts.


But Chrysler repaid all of its government loans, and the government booked a $1.3 billion loss on its $12.5 billion as it completely exited.

Ad Loading...


Taxpayers have recovered $23.2 billion of the $49.5 billion GM bailout, and the Treasury cut its majority stake to 27 percent.


Republicans argue that the companies should have gone through a traditional bankruptcy, seeking funding from banks.


Bush in December 2008 provided $25 billion to GM, Chrysler and their finance arms, saying there was no other choice. "In the midst of a financial crisis and a recession, allowing the U.S. auto industry to collapse is not a responsible course of action," Bush said.


In a Detroit News interview in September, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney said the companies should have gone directly to bankruptcy rather than wait until 2009.


"They needed to move into a managed bankruptcy process rather than getting money up front by President Bush or President Obama," Romney said. "They wasted a lot of money."

Ad Loading...


Critics of Romney's approach say automakers were unprepared for bankruptcy in late 2008 and that without immediate government help they would have been forced into an uncontrolled bankruptcy or collapse.


Ex-car czar Ron Bloom said there was no private financing available in 2009 when GM and Chrysler filed for bankruptcy.


A Democratic National Committee ad on the Web noted that Romney and others suggested automakers wouldn't survive if they got government help. The ad argued that if Republicans were in charge, the headline would have read: "Detroit bankrupt."


Romney dismissed the Obama administration's Midwest campaign pitch touting how the auto bailout helped revive the industry. "If the Democrats are going to point to the economy as a reason to vote for the president, he'll be out of office," he said.


Romney, a Michigan native and son of former Michigan governor George Romney, who ran American Motors, rejected the idea that Republicans were willing to let the auto industry die.

Ad Loading...


"I'm happy to stand up next to anybody in my affection for the auto industry and my conviction that America can compete in automobiles — at home and abroad," Romney said.


At a debate in June, ex-Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum opposed the auto bailout, arguing the companies could have restructured "without the government putting its fingers into it."


Texas Rep. Ron Paul, Minnesota Rep. Michele Bachman, pizza magnate Herman Cain and former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman have all said they opposed the auto bailout.


Michigan Republican Party Chairman Bobby Schostak said Republican candidates have talked about ways to support American manufacturing — and expects it will be a debate topic.


He said Republicans didn't oppose bankruptcies for GM or Chrysler, but the way it was done. The government could have offered loan guarantees as it did in the 1979 Chrysler bailout, Schostak said.

Ad Loading...


He disputed that Obama should get credit for saving the companies. "What saved these companies is that they are selling brands and vehicles that people want to buy," Schostak said.


Michigan voters aren't interested in arguing over the auto bailout, he said. "They are looking at the future: 'Is there a job for me?'" Schostak said. The bailout is "been there, done that. It's time to look ahead."


Sen. Carl Levin, D-Detroit, said it was a "no-brainer" to save the auto industry — and that Republicans will have to explain why they were willing to stand aside. "If we didn't do what we did, we'd probably have one American auto company," Levin said. "It was a no-brainer for Michigan and was a no-brainer for the country to keep manufacturing in this country."


More Industry

Photo of Cadillac Lyriq SUV on road with partly cloudy sky in background
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 16, 2026

Used Autos Selling for More

A recent price spike due to several larger market forces, though it hasn’t dulled demand, is pushing more consumers to efficient models to squeeze in buys.

Read More →
Photo of facade of Waldorf Toyota car dealership
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 16, 2026

Maryland Auto Group Sells

A group out West picked up the major D.C.-area collection, putting it in the upper tiers of private automotive groups in the U.S.

Read More →
Line graphic showing Cox Automotive's March Credit Availability Index status
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 13, 2026

Auto Lending Opens Up in March

Lenders loosened access for subprime borrowers, and consumers with negative equity reached a record high, Cox Automotive reported.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
electric vehicle next to an urban charging station. EV Demand Diverges. F&I and Showroom logo
Industryby Lauren LawrenceApril 10, 2026

EV Interest Varies Regionally

U.S. consumer interest in electric vehicles lags behind other countries despite the rising gas prices caused by the ongoing war in the Middle East.

Read More →
Photo of the rear of a Mercedes GLC 400 electric SUV with a skyline in the background
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 10, 2026

Brands Weighed on Projected Recalls

Research reveals the brands and models most likely to have higher recall rates over their lifetimes. While some brands rank high, addressing safety issues can be a selling point.

Read More →
Photo of white 2026 Ford Bronco on a sandy beach
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 10, 2026

March New-Vehicle Sales Don’t Reflect War

Cox Automotive data shows Americans doubled down on big-is-better despite price increases. Slightly higher incentives helped fuel the demand.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of several cars on lifts in a service center
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 9, 2026

Franchised Dealers Stand to Gain Service Business

Cox Automotive research shows both the opportunities and the challenges in turning consumers’ growing affordability needs into increased fixed-operations revenue.

Read More →
Photo of office desk with open laptop on it and an empty chair next to it
IndustryApril 9, 2026

What Matters Most in Building Your Agency

The partner you choose for growth and expansion is key, because better is the ultimate goal instead of growth for growth’s sake.

Read More →
car with hood open, an arm holding a wrench, The most loyal generation text, Agent Entrepreneur logo
Industryby Lauren LawrenceApril 9, 2026

Service Drives Gen Z Loyalty

The dealership profit center plays an important role in customer retention, and generation Z customers are showing the highest loyalty rates, based on recent CDK Global data.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of man with most of his face hidden as he types on a computer keyboard
Industryby Hannah MitchellApril 2, 2026

Fake Auto Dealer Websites Frauding Consumers

The Point Predictive study traced a pattern across more than 100 websites it believes are being developed by an international theft ring.

Read More →