Chrysler Dealers to Appeal Claims Court Loss
An attorney representing hundreds of former Chrysler franchisees in a $1 billion lawsuit against the federal government plans to file an appeal that could make its way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

In October, the U.S. Court of Federal Claims ruled that hundreds of Chrysler dealers disenfranchised as a condition of a 2009 federal bailout of their manufacturer were not owed compensation under the Fifth Amendment’s Takings Clause.
Photo by AgnosticPreachersKid via Wikimedia Commons
WASHINGTON — A group of about 300 disenfranchised Chrysler dealers will appeal a U.S. Claims Court decision that absolved the federal government of responsibility for the loss of their businesses, attorney Len Bellavia of Bellavia Blatt PC announced.
The plaintiffs are among the 789 dealers whose agreements were terminated in May 2009. The group represented about 25% of Chrysler’s U.S. retail network but accounted for only 14% of sales.
But factory executives didn’t make the decision on their own. An Obama administration task force made trimming Chrysler’s roster a condition of accepting federal funds that kept the manufacturer afloat during a Chapter 11 bankruptcy brought on by plummeting new vehicle sales at the outset of the Great Recession.
Read: FCA, PSA Reach Tentative Merger Deal
Bellavia said the dealers are collectively owed about $1 billion under the Fifth Amendment’s Takings Clause, which requires the federal government to compensate citizens whose private property is seized for public use.
The court denied that claim, pointing in part to testimony from Steven Rattner, the head of the auto task force, and former Chrysler CEO Bob Nardelli. They agreed the factory accepted the terms willingly and in its “best business judgment,” according to Nardelli.
Bellavia expressed disappointment in the verdict but said the 10-year-old case was always likely to wind its way through multiple appeals, whatever the Claims Court decision.
“Both sides understood the trial court was the first step,” Bellavia told Auto Dealer Today. “Even if we won, I would have advised my clients not to take a victory lap. We all knew the appellate court will decide the unique legal issues in this case.”
“It was economic coercion. If Chrysler wanted the bailout, they had to accede to the government’s directive.”
Bellavia stressed that the decision made no note of a provision in the government-drafted loan documents that mandated the closure of a certain number of dealerships. He said this amounted to coercion on the government’s part, an uncommon claim in Takings Clause cases and one to which the court attempted to apply a literal interpretation.
“Coercion in the takings context is not a common matter of proof. ‘Coercion’ connotes this notion of almost a physical force. And that’s not what we were arguing. We weren’t saying the government twisted Chrysler’s arm to file for bankruptcy and terminate dealers,” Bellavia said. “We claimed the coercion as a condition of the bailout. It was economic coercion. If Chrysler wanted the bailout, they had to accede to the government’s directive.”
Originally posted on Auto Dealer Today
More Industry

Pennsylvania Dealership Under New Retailers
The sale of the Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram store puts a family auto group on a leaner path as first-time dealers take the helm.
Read More →
Battery Storage Takes Priority Over EVs
U.S. automakers are prioritizing battery energy stationary storage over electric-vehicle production as the consumer demand for EVs lags the rest of the world.
Read More →
Auto Dealers Feel Better But Not Great
A second-quarter Cox Automotive poll of franchised retailers and independents found better views of the current market after a good spring but anticipation of third-quarter storminess.
Read More →
New-Vehicle Sales Picture Relative
A May forecast is complicated by last spring’s trade tariff effects on auto retail. Despite continued hard realities, many consumers took advantage of ways to bite the bullet.
Read More →
Auto Group Acquires Third Nissan Rooftop
Iowa-based Coleman Automotive Group recently acquired its seventh dealership, McGrath Nissan, which it renamed Nissan of Elgin.
Read More →
April Less Affordable
Based on prices, reduced incentives and slower household income growth, consumers found it more challenging to buy new last month, Cox Automotive reported.
Read More →
Building an Extraordinary F&I Agency
Work to determine your specialized talent, because that fact will determine everything about your agency’s future.
Read More →
Recipe for Compliance
The secret to both amazing barbecue and compliance is the same: understanding the basics and committing to a process.
Read More →
EVs Getting More Attractive
A growing percentage of U.S. consumers are open to switching and fewer are adverse to the idea, according to a recently completed survey. That’s despite the end of a tax break.
Read More →
EV Sales Drop in April Following Surge
North American electric-vehicle sales were down 28% year-over-year, a sharp contrast from global EV sales growth of 6%.
Read More →