Three Big Mistakes Salespeople Make In Negotiating

Three Big Mistakes Salespeople Make In Negotiating
You can have the nicest customer, have done a great job of selling, and have a firm commitment to purchase (total mental ownership) and still lose deals once you pull out the paperwork and try to close it inside (negotiate).
Here are three of the most common and costliest mistakes salespeople make as they start working the deal.
1. Most salespeople lose control.
To be more accurate, most salespeople never had any control. Your first two to three minutes pretty much determine your outcome with every customer. Control starts with your greeting and first few questions. And if you can’t control the direction of the conversation there, good luck negotiating, you’ll definitely need it.
The person asking questions controls the conversation and the direction of the conversation – and that means by asking questions, you control the selling process.
Most salespeople don’t know how to ask questions, but their customers sure do. How much is it? What can I buy it for? What would payments be? How much down? What’s my trade worth? The list is endless, and if you just become an answering machine – you’ll lose almost every sale you could have made.
2. Most salespeople are allowed to take shortcuts.
Too many salespeople take a deal to the desk, and then they work their manager harder than they work the customer. Instead of doing it right, they bring a loose deal, with no paperwork and no real commitment to the manager and say, “I can’t get a commitment, but he’s gonna leave if I don’t give him a price.” So instead of making us do it right, too many managers let us do it wrong in hopes of making the sale.
If you don’t understand the correct way to work a deal, that’s a subject that’s way too big for this article. So get to a sales class and then a closing and negotiation class. Don’t try to shortcut things again, learn to close first and then negotiate. Negotiation is hard if the vehicle wasn’t ‘sold’, or if the deal wasn’t closed correctly. Stop taking shortcuts in your career and you’ll make more money in sales than you ever imagined.
3. Most salespeople focus their selling and negotiating on price.
I know everybody brings up price in some form, every time, on every deal, but price is not what customers buy and it’s almost never their primary concern.
Price wasn’t even on a recent JD Power Top 10 Survey that looked at what buyers want, and it’s #16 on most customers’ priority list after they find a vehicle they want to own. And then when you get to the negotiation, no matter what they say, or even agree to about price, for 94% of the people, it will still depend on fitting the vehicle in their budget because they’ll be making payments.
Learning how to work with price is critical to selling cars, and there are three things you have to learn to do with price:
Bypass… You have to learn to answer their questions like, “How much is it?” and get right back to following the process. It’s extremely easy if you learn how to ask the right questions.
Rephrase... When you get a price objection when you’re closing, you need to rephrase their objection to budget for multiple reasons. That’s easy, too, if you ask the right question.
Refocus... You work deals on price, but their decision to buy will always be based on budget. You have to learn the right questions to take the focus from price back to terms.
When you work this list backwards and learn how to ask questions, learn how to deal with price, and stop taking shortcuts, you’ll have more control and you’ll sell more cars.
More Sales

Nissan Reports Significant Sales Growth
Following the release of Nissan’s 2025 fiscal year report, the automaker announced that its retail-first approach has led to a significant jump in dealer sales.
Read More →
Inventory of New Units Stable
Auto brands spent April clearing out most of their 2025 supply with incentives while holding firm on 2026 prices, striking a balance to meet demand and protect their bottom lines.
Read More →
The Hidden Edge
Reflections from the 2026 Agent Summit: gratitude, gut decisions, and the power of the first contact
Read More →
March New-Vehicle Sales Don’t Reflect War
Cox Automotive data shows Americans doubled down on big-is-better despite price increases. Slightly higher incentives helped fuel the demand.
Read More →
Service Drives Gen Z Loyalty
The dealership profit center plays an important role in customer retention, and generation Z customers are showing the highest loyalty rates, based on recent CDK Global data.
Read More →
EV Sales Slide While Hybrids Climb
California, as usual, led the country in EV registrations in the fourth quarter, but the U.S. as a whole saw a 43% year-over-year volume decrease.
Read More →
Lease Buyouts Deemed Favorable
Better financing conditions and the potential to save money on monthly payments could drive more consumers to buy out their vehicle leases instead of opting for a new lease payment.
Read More →
Black Book: Weekly Market Update
Both vehicle values and conversion rates sped up last week as two segments outperformed in the pre-spring burst of buying.
Read More →
Used-Vehicle Program Aims to Draw More Buyers
GM says more than 750 dealers across the U.S. are enrolled in CarBravo and that in January CarBravo dealers sold over two times the certified volume of Chevrolet, Buick and GMC dealers using traditional CPO.
Read More →
Creating Agency Loyalty
There are tried and true ways to instill it while also protecting your agency from competitors and other roadblocks.
Read More →