How To Follow Up Your Unsold Prospects

How To Follow Up Your Unsold Prospects
Before we talk about how to follow up your working prospects, let’s review what has typically happened in the selling process so far…
86% buy something other than what they said they wanted – and you did have a vehicle in stock they liked.
You spent from 20 minutes to a couple of hours and went through some or all the steps of selling.
For whatever reason – they didn’t buy, so you have one of two choices.
The first option is to blow the time and effort you have already put into this potential sale, send them to your competitor and miss another sale you could be making. Or, learn to get their information before they leave and spend 5 more minutes on follow up to get 1/3 of them back on the lot. This will result in delivering 2 out of 3 of them a vehicle. If you fail to choose the second option, then unfortunately, the first option will be the result by default – another missed sale!
Here’s a very short summary of unsold follow up from one of our online courses. Of course there’s way more to learn, but follow these quick directions and you’ll start selling more now. Your only goal with follow up is to sell an appointment. Not the vehicle or the price, just an appointment that shows.
Get their phone number first – their cell phone number is best and get their permission to text them). Then get their email & mailing address – or you can’t follow up. Don’t ask, “Can I get your number?” Just ask, “What’s your best number?” Next, get their email, street address and finally, “Spell your last name.”
Send a text within minutes. One that works with just about everyone is: “Bob, make a U-turn quick, my manager has a buyer for your trade and wants to take a look at it.” Your manager does have a buyer.
If you get no response from your text, call them as soon as possible with the same urgent message.
Within an hour, send an email to say thank you for stopping by. Add personal ‘PS’ and repeat the ‘trade’ urgency.
At the end of the day, put a ‘thank you’ note in the mail.
Next day – call them again with ‘new’ information.
Call them again and again until they buy somewhere. Even if not from you, put them on your Master List.
One final tip - talk with your manager on exactly what to do and say.
Why does follow up work so well? That’s easy...
You built rapport and gave them a good presentation.
You made a great impression with your follow up.
They enjoy recognition and appreciate the contact.
They want to deal with someone they ‘like’.
And – none of your competition did any of this!
So why not follow up to make another 6 - 10 sales per month? You have to work tomorrow, either way!
More Sales

New-Car Demand on the Rise
For the first time this year, new-vehicle demand rose in May, up nearly 6% year-over-year, according to CarGurus’ Intelligence Report.
Read More →
Auto Prices Ride May Moderation
Flat ATPs and asking prices clocked in below long-term averages for the month, though some segments saw significant price gains, reported Cox Automotive.
Read More →
Nissan Reports Significant Sales Growth
Following the release of Nissan’s 2025 fiscal year report, the automaker announced that its retail-first approach has led to a significant jump in dealer sales.
Read More →
Inventory of New Units Stable
Auto brands spent April clearing out most of their 2025 supply with incentives while holding firm on 2026 prices, striking a balance to meet demand and protect their bottom lines.
Read More →
The Hidden Edge
Reflections from the 2026 Agent Summit: gratitude, gut decisions, and the power of the first contact
Read More →
March New-Vehicle Sales Don’t Reflect War
Cox Automotive data shows Americans doubled down on big-is-better despite price increases. Slightly higher incentives helped fuel the demand.
Read More →
Service Drives Gen Z Loyalty
The dealership profit center plays an important role in customer retention, and generation Z customers are showing the highest loyalty rates, based on recent CDK Global data.
Read More →
EV Sales Slide While Hybrids Climb
California, as usual, led the country in EV registrations in the fourth quarter, but the U.S. as a whole saw a 43% year-over-year volume decrease.
Read More →
Lease Buyouts Deemed Favorable
Better financing conditions and the potential to save money on monthly payments could drive more consumers to buy out their vehicle leases instead of opting for a new lease payment.
Read More →
Black Book: Weekly Market Update
Both vehicle values and conversion rates sped up last week as two segments outperformed in the pre-spring burst of buying.
Read More →