agent Entrepreneur logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

How to Avoid the 3 Most Common New-Manager Mistakes

August 15, 2018
3 min to read



Congratulations on your new role as a manager!



Now what?

Ad Loading...



You're suddenly responsible for the career trajectories of people who aren't yourself. And with that comes new a set of responsibilities, perspectives, and skills, reports Inc. 



It's no small task, and without being mindful of common mistakes, it's easy to mishandle. I take pride in being a good manager. I focus a lot of my attention on managing my direct reports and think effective management is the most important aspect of my job. But managing didn't always come naturally to me and I've made my fair share of mistakes along the way.



Here are the three most common mistakes I've seen new managers make, as well as some advice on how to avoid doing the same.


1. Having micromanager-phobia



Even if you haven't been directly exposed to one, you surely know someone who has suffered under the dreaded "micromanager."

Ad Loading...


For those who have worked for one, the reactions are strong and unanimous: "This stifles my creativity. I can't work this way. I'll never be this type of manager."



Far too often, the next step is overcompensation. The new manager becomes so fearful of being labeled a micromanager that he or she ends up not managing anything at all.



Part of managing involves telling people what to do. Rookie managers often mistake this for micromanaging. However, ordering directs to do things a certain way, doing it for them, or pointing out a mistake without correcting it are qualities of a micromanager.



Checking in with people to make sure they're on track. Asking to see results. Asking to see a report. Asking to be kept in the loop. Asking to join a call to see how someone's doing. These are all things every manager is expected to do. And that's the difference.



Every one of your direct reports will be different, but find a balance that gives all of them the freedom to get things done independently but also stresses accountability.

Ad Loading...


2. Being the "friend boss"


Another new-manager fail? Being the friend boss. Don't be the friend boss.


Of course, you want your workplace to be a friendly environment. Of course you want to be kind and caring with all of your colleagues. And, of course, you want to have fun together. At my company, Arkadium, we have a "joy team" dedicated to organizing fun outings for everyone in our company. Fostering a friendly and fun environment is super important to good workplace culture.



But never confuse being someone's manager with being a best friend--it will almost always lead to uncomfortable situations, especially when it's time to have challenging conversations. Giving constructive feedback or addressing poor performance, for example, can easily be misconstrued when your direct report is under the impression that you're supposed to be friends.



As a manager, you're responsible for somebody's career trajectory, growth, and compensation. Executing all those responsibilities while simultaneously being a friend is a balancing act that no effective manager would recommend.

Ad Loading...



Authenticity is the key to any relationship, in and out of the office. Being a best friend and a manager at the same time just isn't authentic.


3. Keeping your door too open



An open-door policy is important. Your direct reports should feel comfortable enough to communicate with you. But there's a fine line between having an open door and making yourself too available.



Do your direct reports have a question about the email cadence between your account manager and a partner? That's perfectly valid--they need that information to properly do their job. Should you fulfill your direct reports' request to proofread every one of their emails before they press send? Of course not.



Don't be an enabler by giving the impression that you need to sign off on every small decision. By stunting someone's independence, you make it difficult for that person to learn and grow in his or her role.

Ad Loading...



Be genuine, be open, and don't hesitate to draw lines in the sand. Being a new manager isn't the minefield some expect it to be.


Topics:Training
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Training

Businessman signing document with pen
Training•October 1, 2026

Turning Regulatory Pressure Into Profitable Performance

A compliance-first F&I Strategy for today's auto dealer is essential given recent enforcement actions on the state and federal level. Here’s how to help your dealer-clients establish it.

Read More →
Empty classroom with lecturn, chairs and video proejction screen
Training•by Rick McCormick•September 16, 2026

Major Shifts in F&I Training

General agents must help F&I managers rise to the occasion of the modern consumer, who has very different expectations in order to relax into trust.

Read More →
Photo of financial documents with a magnifying glass, calculator and pen on top
Training•by Hannah Mitchell•August 31, 2026

Be a Compliance Hero

Agents can steer their dealer clients toward proper advertising practices, including regular audits, to help keep them on the straight and narrow in a period of elevated regulation.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of man signing document with a blue pen
Training•by Gil Van Over•July 28, 2026

Leasing Is Picking Up. What About Disclosures?

Agents and dealers must ensure proper documentation of lease costs and funding and end the practice of wedging lease orders into buyer’s orders — or ignoring them.

Read More →
'CHANGES' spelled out in two-dimensional letters on a concrete-like surface
Training•by David R. Ibarra•July 8, 2026

Manage Change, or It Will Manage You

Two retail tales from the pandemic paint a stark contrast in the wise approach and the defensive move that will undercut success rather than build on it.

Read More →
Marble statue holding hands to face.
Training•by Justin B. Gasman•June 5, 2026

Train the Mind, Grow the Department

Agents who want to create real value must do more than bring coverage options. They must help dealers build stronger thinking, better habits and better results.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of a stack of folded newspapers on a table
Training•by Gil Van Over•May 7, 2026

Headlines Can Be Deceiving

Warning letters the FTC sent to dealers suspected of deceptive pricing have retailers and the agents who counsel them on edge. Read past the headlines to get and stay compliant.

Read More →
Photo of mechanic wiping his hands on a rag
Training•by Hannah Mitchell•March 12, 2026

Service Drive Satisfaction Up

Auto dealerships have a ways to go, though, on many basic points, along with some new consumer expectations that would boost their competitiveness if fulfilled.

Read More →
Photo of man's hand holding a pen above a piece of paper on a desk
Training•by Rick McCormick•March 11, 2026

Agents Bring the Message and the Focus

The most predictable profit in today's unpredictable automotive retail market is a dealership’s finance-and-insurance department.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Training•February 19, 2026

Policy Responses to Data Breaches

The recent 700Credit cyberattack is a wake-up call for agents and dealers. Review disclosures and tighten vendor oversight to maintain compliance and preserve customer trust.

Read More →
Ad Loading...